Butterfinger Cake

Nothing like sneaking in a post on the last day of the month, just so that the entire month of June wouldn’t go by without a post from me! Honestly, I haven’t been cooking a lot. If you’ve been around for awhile, you know I lean towards baking… lots of yummy and fattening goodies! Well, I’ve been on Weight Watchers for almost three months now, and that just doesn’t lend itself well to baking lots of yummy cookies and brownies and cheesecakes, oh my. While not very good for my blog, it has been good for my waistline- 20.6 lbs down as of this past Sunday.

Anyway, as usual, I’m behind in blogging and with no good excuse — today’s recipe was made on Mother’s Day. It’s a Butterfinger Cake that I found at Southern Plate. Super easy to make, and DELICIOUS. I did plenty of breaking my diet the day I made this, and that surely included a gigantic serving of this dessert.

Butterfinger Cake

You’ll need: Devil’s Food Cake Mix (plus the eggs/oil/ingredients requested on the box), caramel topping, condensed milk, butterfingers, and Cool Whip

IMG_0510

Make the Devil’s Food Cake according to the directions on the box.

IMG_0507

In a small bowl, add your jar of caramel topping. I used this 2-cup glass measuring cup because it has a pour spout. That will be important in a minute.

IMG_0508

Add the can of sweetened condensed milk.

IMG_0509

Give it a good stir until they are mostly combined.

IMG_0512

Go back to your still warm devil’s food cake. Take a fork and stab the cake. Really go at it, until it is covered with poke holes.

IMG_0513

Pour the caramel mixture over your holey cake.

IMG_0514

Pour it all on there, and let it start soaking in. It might take awhile.

IMG_0505

In the meantime, crush your butterfinger bars. Obviously, I crushed mine a little earlier in the process because that’s the full can of sweetened condensed milk I’m using in this picture.

IMG_0516

Spread most of the crushed Butterfinger over your cake. Then stick it in the fridge for awhile to continue settling and soaking up that delicious caramel sauce.

IMG_0517

Before serving, top cake with the container of cool whip and sprinkle with the remaining Butterfinger crumbles.

YUM!

Butterfinger Cake
Source: Southern Plate

1 box devil’s food cake
1 bottle caramel topping
1 can sweetened condensed milk
1 tub cool whip
Butterfinger bar

Prepare cake according to package directions. Immediately after removing cake from oven, poke several holes all over the top with a fork. Mix sweetened condensed milk and caramel together, pour over hot cake, spread it over the entire cake. Chill well. After cake has chilled completely, spread cool whip over the top and sprinkle crushed Butterfinger bar on top of cool whip.

6 Comments so far

  1. the crazy suburban mom on July 1st, 2010

    Oh man, I just happened upon your blog and all I can say as someone who has been dieting since last july IM SO SCARED OF THIS CAKE!

    And I’m not sure if I should book mark the page or run screaming!

    LOL
    Tracy

  2. Mi Cocina on July 18th, 2010

    OMG… This looks sooooooo yummy.. I can’t stop salivating.. I think I just drooled all over the keyboard… WISH I could eat thissssss….

    Lisa C.

  3. RE - RecycledFrockery on August 5th, 2010

    ooooooooooo girl ! that cake looks sinfully delicious. honey chile I’m gonna try this one this weekend. if it’s good, I may try to give it for the next persons birthday cake. I give cakes alot and this looks like a real winner. so when you gonna post again sugar ? we love your recipes.

  4. Saturday Sharing | 1stopmom on August 7th, 2010

    [...] Cooks: You have to check out this recipe for Butterfinger Cake! Seeing all the pictures made me want to get up and make [...]

  5. Jennifer C. on August 15th, 2010

    Hi Jenn! I found your blog through Foy’s e-mail. I love to see what other Hoosiers are cooking! (I’m in Evansville) I have made this cake before, but I have never used Butterfinger. One time I used Reese’s, another time M & Ms and for our family Christmas party, I used crushed up peppermint. I have to say, the peppermint was the best!

  6. christy on December 18th, 2010

    How long will this keep in the fridge?

Leave a reply

FireStats icon Powered by FireStats